- DTN Headline News
Judge: 'Ag-Gag' Law Unconstitutional
Monday, August 3, 2015 5:30PM CDT

By Chris Clayton
DTN Ag Policy Editor

OMAHA (DTN) -- A federal judge granted a summary judgment on Monday to an animal-rights group, ruling that an Idaho law against videotaping farm operations is unconstitutional.

The Animal Legal Defense Fund had filed a lawsuit last year against Idaho's governor and attorney general. Idaho is one of seven states with a specific law seeking to prevent whistleblowers from secretly recording on farms. Most of the laws involve fines for providing false information on job applications as a way to get into farms.

The group Mercy for Animals released a video last year showing cattle being abused at an Idaho dairy. The video sparked the Idaho Dairymen's Association to champion a bill criminalizing undercover videos that exposed potentially abusive scenes at livestock facilities. The law made "interference with agricultural production" a crime. Anyone convicted of videotaping animal abuse or safety violations without getting the owner's permission first could face a year in jail. Moreover, a journalist or whistleblower could be forced to pay restitution for economic losses due to the result of a story revealing animal abuse or unsafe working conditions.

U.S. District Judge B. Lynn Winmill stated in his ruling that the law sought to limit and punish people who spoke out against topics related to agriculture, which Winmill stated was effectively "striking at the heart of important First Amendment values."

Winmill cited the story of Upton Sinclair and his book, "The Jungle," which exposed Chicago's meat-packing industry early in the 20th century and led to federal laws regarding meat inspection. Winmill noted Idaho's law would have essentially made Sinclair's conduct criminal. Winmill stated the public has a strong interest in how food is produced and how livestock that produce food are treated.

Winmill cited statements from Idaho legislators made during debate over the bill as lawmakers criticized animal-rights groups and their motives. Lawmakers claimed the bill was needed to protect the dairy industry from other undercover operations.

The judge noted that the Idaho law represents "a particularly serious threat to whistleblowers' free speech rights." Moreover, criminal and civil laws already exist to protect people from false statements.

"The State's logic is perverse -- in essence the State says that (1) powerful industries deserve more government protection than smaller industries, and (2) the more attention and criticism an industry draws, the more the government should protect that industry from negative publicity or other harms."

Neither Idaho state officials nor representatives from ALDF responded Monday afternoon to the judge's decision.

Chris Clayton can be reached at Chris.Clayton@dtn.com

Follow him on Twitter @ChrisClaytonDTN

(AG)


blog iconDTN Blogs & Forums
DTN Market Matters Blog
Katie Micik
Markets Editor
Monday, July 27, 2015 7:01PM CDT
Tuesday, July 21, 2015 7:40PM CDT
Monday, July 20, 2015 3:45PM CDT
Technically Speaking
Darin Newsom
DTN Senior Analyst
Sunday, August 2, 2015 6:06PM CDT
Sunday, August 2, 2015 4:24PM CDT
Sunday, August 2, 2015 4:00PM CDT
Fundamentally Speaking
Joel Karlin
DTN Contributing Analyst
Friday, July 31, 2015 9:00PM CDT
Thursday, July 30, 2015 2:34PM CDT
Thursday, July 23, 2015 3:20PM CDT
DTN Ag Policy Blog
Chris Clayton
DTN Ag Policy Editor
Tuesday, August 4, 2015 4:18PM CDT
Friday, July 31, 2015 9:17PM CDT
Thursday, July 30, 2015 3:00PM CDT
Minding Ag's Business
Marcia Taylor
DTN Executive Editor
Tuesday, July 28, 2015 9:41PM CDT
Monday, July 27, 2015 6:27PM CDT
Wednesday, July 22, 2015 3:57PM CDT
DTN Ag Weather Forum
Bryce Anderson
DTN Ag Meteorologist and DTN Analyst
Monday, August 3, 2015 12:33AM CDT
Thursday, July 30, 2015 3:33PM CDT
Wednesday, July 29, 2015 3:48PM CDT
DTN Production Blog
Pam Smith
Crops Technology Editor
Friday, July 24, 2015 8:10PM CDT
Monday, July 13, 2015 7:07PM CDT
Friday, June 19, 2015 7:19PM CDT
Harrington's Sort & Cull
John Harrington
DTN Livestock Analyst
Friday, July 31, 2015 5:58PM CDT
Friday, July 17, 2015 7:58PM CDT
Thursday, July 2, 2015 6:04PM CDT
South America Calling
Alastair Stewart
South America Correspondent
Tuesday, August 4, 2015 3:32PM CDT
Thursday, July 30, 2015 2:47PM CDT
Monday, July 27, 2015 7:59PM CDT
An Urban’s Rural View
Urban Lehner
Editor Emeritus
Tuesday, August 4, 2015 11:15AM CDT
Monday, July 27, 2015 9:53PM CDT
Tuesday, July 21, 2015 3:18PM CDT
Machinery Chatter
Jim Patrico
Progressive Farmer Senior Editor
Monday, August 3, 2015 4:47PM CDT
Tuesday, July 28, 2015 10:04PM CDT
Tuesday, July 14, 2015 10:18PM CDT
Canadian Markets
Cliff Jamieson
Canadian Grains Analyst
Friday, July 24, 2015 9:27PM CDT
Thursday, July 23, 2015 9:19PM CDT
Wednesday, July 22, 2015 10:00PM CDT
Editor’s Notebook
Greg D. Horstmeier
DTN Editor-in-Chief
Wednesday, July 29, 2015 4:02PM CDT
Tuesday, July 14, 2015 7:45PM CDT
Wednesday, July 8, 2015 7:45PM CDT
 
Copyright DTN. All rights reserved. Disclaimer.
Powered By DTN